20 Best Vegan Waterproof Mascara (2022 Updated)

I’m so excited @covergirl wanted to collaborate with me on their Clean and fresh makeup line. All 4 products are amazing The concealer is so lightweight and smooth and does an amazing job of covering up as well as contouring.

The clean and fresh skin milk was so silky and hydrating. It blended easily and left a dewy glow on my skin. The clean and fresh healthy look pressed powder was so light and breathable it left my skin looking smooth and fresh.

All the products are vegan and free of sulfates, parabens, formaldehyde and talc. Last but not least is the clean and fresh voluminous mascara. This leaves my lashes with 10x the volume of bare lashes it is specially formulated to condition your lashes and has unique brush technology.

It doesn’t smudge or clump and lasts all day! You definitely have to try the CoverGirl clean and fresh line #beauty #love #beautiful #fashion #makeup #instagood #style #photography #model #photooftheday #like #instagram #gotitfree #follow #skincare #cute #girl #nature #photo #picoftheday #happy #smile #bhfyp #life #me #selfie #covergirlcanada #myself #makeupartist #likeforlikes.

First, I see a lot of reviews complaining this mascara is hard to take off which has me laughing. Waterproof formulations SHOULD be difficult to take off without the right eye makeup remover otherwise (hello!) the mascara would smudge over the course of the day.

If you can’t get on board with the removal process simply stop using this one – there are plenty of non-waterproof mascaras out there for you. Because I’m really active and live in a humid environment, I have sworn by waterproof mascara since high school (I’m now in my late 20s).

I’ve tried a lot of different mascaras over the years and the best, most long-lasting ones tend to be manufactured by luxury makeup brands and cost upwards $27 for a single tube. This mascara blows them all out of the water and is less than a third of the price.

And on top of that, it is vegan, cruelty free, and made with clean ingredients! I don’t know how you do it but you’ve found a loyal convert for life. Please don’t discontinue this product.

I have been using Covergirl mascaras since I was a teen. But as I have gotten older, I have developed allergies. With those allergies I have stopped using many beauty products and even change my diet.

I tried other mascara brands and the irritation on my eyes was just unbearable. I even started getting eyelash extension because I couldn’t use mascara. But with eyelash extensions came a lot of issues with my natural lashes falling out and thinning out.

So, I was in a situation where I was out of options. But when I saw this new cleaner vegan mascara option from Covergirl I knew I had to try it. Thank goodness I did because this mascara has changed my life! My eyes do not burn or itch at all.

My eyelashes have grown longer and fuller naturally and I love it!!! I use this mascara daily, and I remove it with just soap and water. No messy stains or harsh scrubbing needed. I highly recommend this mascara to anyone that has allergies or issues with mascaras in the past.

Thank you Covergirl for this!!!!!.

From the moment I tried Lash Princess Green I’ve been a fan. I stood in the back of the line when lush, long, thick lashes were handed out and so definitely need help. Help is what you’ll get from this mascara and goooood! My lashes look twice, if not thrice as long and they’ll even have some volume go ‘up’ a tad (Yeah, I know, weird, but I have a slight lash curler phobia, never use one).

It is also easy to apply, no spider legs, nor needing 3 coats to get results. 1 dip per eye and I suddenly look alive. and even decent!! The price for this great mascara is ridiculously low too. €3, something (Tip: if you decide to like it, get a backup in buying round 2.

In my drugstore it is either always sold out or with just 1 or 2 remaining. ) Performs better than some high end ones I tried. If there’s one thing that prevents me from giving 5 stars, it’s that the emulsion is – how to say it – a little ‘dry-ish’.

It feels ‘stiffer’ somehow than other mascaras and you can notice that with application even though it still runs smooth – therefore hard to explain. Maybe this is why it makes my lashes quite hard when dry.

A lot of mascaras do that though, but one of my other favourites (L’Oréal Collagen 24hrs volume mascara) makes them feel soft and pliable, so I’m “ruined” because of that ;). They’ve not broken because of it yet – important to note since I’ve been using this 6+ years now -, so it could be just me whining over nothing.

A. k. a nitpicking. I’ve nothing more to say. Just go try it. but only the black Lash Princess with green lettering. The others are rubbish imho.

I’ve been sitting on getting this one for awhile, but I finally had to throw away Better Than Sex and I was on a budget. I HIGHLY recommend this mascara, especially if you’re on a budget. I would also recommend using an eyelash separator.

That’s my only issue besides the wand being a little big (but I have an issue with most mascara wands regarding that; I have to use mini brushes or be careful). I used length because that’s what I was going for, and it’s GREAT.

I can’t wear falsies because constant facial spasms (I have a neurological condition) caused my right eyelid to change texture/elasticity, so I HAVE to use mascara since even magnetic eyelashes do not stick on.

I recommend this to anyone from beginners, people on a budget, to people who don’t care either way. It makes your eyelashes long. I will say, I noticed that it didn’t stay curled when I was in California for an anime convention (I am mostly Native American, so my hair doesn’t hold the best curl), but that’s nothing that a quick eyelash curler can’t fix.

People in more humid places might have to recurl if they have straight lashes like mine The pictures are of my face with one eye done (one eye with Lash Princess, one without, no curler), lashes without Lash Princess, and lashes WITH Lash Princess.

That’s how good this mascara is!.

I have tried a lot of mascaras over the years because I love a thick long bold lash. I’ve tried more expensive ones and a million drugstore ones. Someone gave me this mascara years ago to try and I haven’t use anything else since, and never will! I pair this with white lash primer before applying, and I constantly am asked what kind of mascara I use and/or if my lashes are fake.

Seriously, like once a month. And trust me I do not have long or thick lashes at all. I’m also really lazy and hate removing eye makeup, but this removes so easily while it lasts all day (I remove with micellar water and only need one cotton pad).

Even though this isn’t waterproof, I haven’t had issues with smudging or smearing unless I use I use my thick zinc oxide sunscreens in the summer. even then it’s minimal. I have really bad allergies and my eyes water all the time so I used to religiously use waterproof mascara until this because it somehow manages to stay.

I haven’t tried their waterproof yet, but I plan to for those summer days when I slather on the thick oily sunscreen. Long story short, believe all the hype and buy it right now. It’s sorcery.

The only stars this mascara gets are for glass bottle packaging, cruelty free/vegan certs, and easiest removal at the end of the day. My lashes wipe off with water and fingertips, something I have never experienced before!! But let’s get to the rest.

The brush. The brush! Just why? The bristles are thick and chunky, very chunky on the outer edges. When you apply the mascara, the only distribution of product is on the outer corners and the middle of the brush is so difficult to place into the middle of the lashes.

No separation. Next, the formula. Wet and clumpy!!! I understand this is a conditioning formula but golly! If you apply onto a curled lash, they are gonna wilt. They are going to transfer. This mascara takes a long time to dry.

I even tested out the sister conditioning lash serum and the two together are a whole mess! I do not understand the hype around this mascara. Unless you have naturally long, curled lashes that do not touch your skin at any part of the day and you live in a place with -17% humidity, this mascara is pointless.

Finishing the bottle and moving on quicker than my last ex. Hopefully this review saves someone some time and money!.

This is by far Pacifica’s best mascara. However, there are some aspects of it that still set it behind other vegan mascaras, such as Thrive Causemetics liquid lash extensions mascara. For example, removing it is difficult, it’s not waterproof but doesn’t like to come off with water, it just smears everywhere.

Even with eye make up remover, this is tough mascara to get off your face. It comes off your lashes, but then smears all over your skin which is annoying. Thrive’s mascara easily comes off with water and doesn’t smear, which I like better.

Additionally, the word “fluffy” makes me think this mascara will make my lashes softer, longer, and, well, fluffier. However, this mascara makes your lashes very stiff and hard, almost crunchy. They look longer and fuller, but they are definitely not what I would define as “fluffy”, since there is no softness to your lashes when using this mascara.

Pros: 1. glass packaging is more environmentally friendly and is very beautiful 2. Vegan brush is nice, it’s Pacifica’s best brush so far 3. Using in conjunction with the primer gives you great looking lashes Cons: 1.

Hard to remove, smears all over your face when trying to remove it and doesn’t come off easily 2. Lashes are hard and almost crunchy when it dries, not soft and fluffy like advertised 3. Difficult to prevent lashes from clumping when applying, might be a result of the brush bristles being so far apart Overall, this mascara is worth trying at the price point it is at, but there are still better vegan mascaras out there.

This is my first experience of a vegan mascara hence I was quite excited to try it. Like vegan I found the mascara very natural and did not clump. If you are looking for a natural look this would be perfect.

Unfortunately it wasn’t what I look for in a mascara, it didn’t lengthen my lashes, or hold my curls when I curled my lashes. Although its waterproof I did find that I was able to remove it with ease with micellar water which was a pleasant change as I find that most waterproof mascara take me a lot of effort to remove which at times would ruin my skin.

I definitely found this low irritating and suitable for sensitive eyes like myself. Initially with the first few uses I found that when I put the wand back into the tube a mass of product would squeeze out on top which would be quite messy however this disappeared after a handful of uses.

I also found that this would often smudge under my eyes as well despite multiple attempts of powdering or trying other techniques. I think if the formula could be slightly improve to provide length and hold curls I would definitely consider this again as its a vegan product.

I was gifted a product sample to trial and review.

Needed a more natural looking mascara with fewer nasty ingredients. Have loved multiple other products from Ere Perez. The mascara is a little on the dry side as others have mentioned, but I didn’t find it flaky at all, and the drier formula actually allows great separate lash definition.

It’s less subtle than I was expecting as it does add quite a bit of volume. However, my main issue with this product is how hard it is to remove! I’m aware this is a waterproof formula but I expected it to at least remove some of it when using my regular cleanser, which removes all my other make up without issue.

But after a full cleanse it was like I hadn’t touched it! I had a freshly cleansed face with full mascara on! I then had to scrub with makeup remover but some residue was STILL leftover and was under my eyes the next day.

The second issue is that despite it’s ability to stay put through cleansing it actually tranfers onto the under eye area quite badly during the day, another problem I’m not used to having. I was previously using Bare Minerals Lash Domination and it would stay put PERFECTLY all day then magically come off at night with a bit of cleanser and water.

I’ll probably go back to that formula.

I was excited about this mascara based on the majority of reviews, but I must agree with the dissenters in this list. For one, I don’t find this product to be fragrance free at all. It has a distinct odor I could still smell even after it had been on my lashes for a little while.

As other reviewers mentioned, it has a thin consistency, which I didn’t like. It didn’t do much for me and in spite of it being thinner, I was very aware of it being on my eyes. My skin is pretty sensitive and I found it the slightest bit irritating while wearing it.

Not comfortable. The wand I especially didn’t like. It’s huge and a weird cone shape that was awkward during the application. Just all around not great. The packaging is nice and the tube is attractive, but that was about the only plus.

Glad to see it works for others, but it’s a no from me.

I LOVE LOVE LOVE the wand. The deep curve really helps hug the very bottom of my lashes. The color is a great, deep black, and though it definitely looks like I’m wearing mascara, it’s not a LOOK I AM WEARING MAKEUP look.

That being said, it’s not as volumizing as it is lengthening. My lashes look mostly the same except a little more curled and sky-high as opposed to thicker and making it look like I have more lash than I do.

It’s a great look, and I’ll probably use this often in tandem with possibly the vegan collagen mascara. The wand is fabulous. Now, where it really shines, however, is on my bottom lashes. I don’t know how it’s not super volumizing for my upper lashes, but my bottom lashes look AMAZING with this.

Thicker, longer, darker, AND INCREDIBLY NATURAL. Can’t explain how it works like this, but as far as my bottom lashes go, no complaints!.

I received this as part of a promotion from Pacifica. I have blonde lashes and want a product that covers, stays, and does not irritate my sensitive eyes. I tested alone and with the Fluffy lash serum underneath.

I prefer it without the serum underneath. It does a good job of covering the blonde, and looks very natural (not too full or long) for a work day or daytime look. I have not had any issues with the mascara shedding, even in the summer, humid heat.

The wand shape is great for getting those lower lashes without stabbing your eye. I also would love Pacifica to have more color options for mascara, such as brown or burgundy, for all the blonde/redhead ladies out there.

To be up front, I received this item as a promotional product from Pacifica. That being said, this mascara is a wonderful new addition to my collection! It actually is the most natural, non-clumpy mascara I have ever used, and I can even use it on my lower lashes without it looking overdone.

Feels very light when it dries. accidentally rubbed my eye while wearing because I forgot it was there- BUT it only flaked a tiny bit and caused NO smudging! This mascara is my new go-to for everyday.

incredibly easy to wear natural or glam it up. The only reason I gave 4 stars is because the price is a bit high for my budget, but I can definitely see myself purchasing during a sale (especially if they release it in brown! ).

This is the one. As an Asian monolid with stick straight stubby eyelashes that point straight down, it doesn’t get more struggle bus central with the panda eyes than me. My go to used to be urban decay cannonball, but then they discontinued it and I basically gave up wearing mascara.

Let me tell you, this is way better than the UD cannonball. I live in Miami Florida and it is incredibly humid here. I also work anywhere from 12-30 hours at a time at the hospital. Let’s be real no mascara can last 30 hours…but 12 hours after being in the operating room all day? Lashes still curled and no under-eye smudging.

Even at hour 24 there is a whisper of a curl left lol. I also go straight from work to the gym so I’ve tested it in humid sweaty Florida conditions. If I sweat heavily the mascara fades evenly and somehow doesn’t smudge at all under my eyes.

And it doesn’t sting my eyes either. On top of this, the wand is thin and the perfect curved shape. It works on my barely existent bottom lashes. The forumula isn’t clumpy and doesn’t have fibers that fall into your eyes throughout the day.

It also doesn’t irritate my eyes at all and I have sensitive eczema-prone eyelids. Please don’t ever stop carrying this product.

This is my absolute favourite mascara. I have tried so many. I have eyelashes that are strong and point straight, going down slightly. It is an absolute pain to curl them and have them stay lifted the whole day.

To stay up, the mascara has to be light-weight, waterproof and long lasting. This mascara ticks every single box. The formula is great, it has never leaked. Moreover, it is exactly my style. It makes the eyelashes super long and flutter-y, separated and super pretty.

Doesn’t weight my eyelashes down at all and I have barely any lash loss when I take off the mascara. I got the brown one and the colour is so pretty and delicate looking. I have already repurchased after losing my first one and hope it comes soon.

The effect is so beautiful and I get compliments about how long my eyelashes look. Clio also chose a reliable wand type that suits the mascara. It came with a gentle curved brush that is quite sturdy but not too harsh, it’s also a little flexible.

Love the brush, it easily coats my eyelashes evenly and is easy to knock product off. It gets all the hard to reach corner lashes too. Since the brush is quite thin, I also haven’t knocked mascara onto my cheeks yet.

It doesn’t have much of a scent either. I like the packaging, easy to put in a thin makeup bag. I will be buying some of the other mascaras in this line.

This mascara is heaven sent. It’s definitely on the drier side, which is ideal for those with straighter lashes as it won’t weigh them down, and instead keep the curls up all day. I also love that the wand is on the smaller side so it prevents the mascara from getting all over the lid.

It also doesn’t smudge/transfer, clump, or flake on me at all. It’s seriously one of the best mascaras that I’ve tried. But do keep in mind that these give more of a natural look (imo anyways). They kind of just coat the lashes and tints them.

I don’t find that they really do much volumizing or lengthening (both for the black and brown mascara, but maybe if you do more than one coat). They’re great for an everyday look.

I really, really, REALLY wanted to LOVE this mascara. I wanted this to be the one for me, the one mascara that ended like 10+ years of me trying out different mascaras from different brands and never being satisfied with the results.

I wanted this one to be the one that finally checked all my boxes and actually lived up to all its claims. Especially since the company is so dedicated to giving back to communities in need, I loved that part and I still love that, regardless of how I feel about the mascara.

Unfortunately, the mascara did not work for me. It was a little finnicky to apply, the formula is very, VERY wet, so I always tried to work fast with it. The first time I used it, I only did 2 coats for each eye, the eye I started with my lashes looked clumpy, spidery, and were weighed down by the formula.

But my second eye looked great!– the lashes were long, feathery, separated, defined– at least for the first few hours. Then both my eyes the lashes became very weighed down by the formula and they started flaking quite a bit, getting black mascara chunks all over my face and some even in my eyes, which was uncomfortable.

But I after that first day I thought maybe I did something wrong so I continued to use the mascara for about a month. I tried everything I could think of to apply it. I tried wiping excess mascara off the wand with a tissue before applying, focusing on the base of my lashes, focusing just on the tips, turning the wand direction, rolling the wand, flicking the wand, pressing with the wand focusing on only certain points of my lashes, I watched several YouTube video tutorials on how to use the mascara but no matter what I just could not get it to look good consistently.

Even when I would think I had come up with a technique that seemed to work, when I would apply the mascara again for a few days in a row using that same method, the results would be mixed at best, and at worst they would get progressively worse.

That’s without even mentioning the fact that the mascara never lasted unscathed to the end of the day, continuing to flake flake, sometimes to the point of almost seemingly to have flaked completely off, but I know that’s not the case because I would still get little black chunks in the sink after my initial oil cleanse every night.

I finally gave up on the mascara after one night time removal that particularly spooked me, to say the least. I had had I bad day for some reason that day and when I met up with my boyfriend for a casual date that night I ended up ugly crying to him about it.

It was embarrassing how messy the mascara, it got reactivated by my tears and became a streaky, wet, but somehow STILL flakey mess. I did my best to wipe it all off and by the time I got home about an hour later and when I went to remove my makeup some of my lashes SNAPPED OFF with the mascara!!! And yes, I’m sure it wasn’t just the mascara and how it comes off in tubes because I could see the base of my lashes hair sticking out of the bottom of the “tube”, I noticed several lashes exactly like this.

And the next day I decided not to use the mascara anymore because I did notice some thin spots along one of my upper lash lines. I have since found through some Google research that tubing mascaras can be drying to eyelashes in the right (or more like wrong) circumstances, and dry eyelashes are more likely to break.

Crying and then not being able to properly remove the mascara for an hour so may be one of those circumstances. I’m not saying this mascara is bad, I don’t think think that. I’m just saying I know it’s not for me, and to be honest, now I don’t even tubing mascaras in general are for me.

From what I’ve discovered online since my experience with this mascara, it seems like people either love or hate tubing mascaras, like they just do or don’t work for them for whatever reason. For me, it doesn’t and I won’t be buying this mascara again or recommending it to anyone because I just can’t do that in good faith after the experience I had.

But that definitely does not mean I have given up on this company and will never buy from them again, on the contrary, I’d love to find thrive products I can’t live without and hope to try some more of their products– just never this mascara again.

I just used the mascara that I received for the first time, and while I don’t usually leave negative reviews this went beyond not liking the product so I had to share. Going on the mascara was okay, didn’t love the brush because it took a lot of swipes and wiggles to get my lashes evenly coated, but since I work 12hr over night shifts often wearing a face shield or safety glasses, I had high hopes for this waterproof mascara.

Also being in Florida humidity I was hopeful it wouldn’t smudge or give me raccoon eyes. Well I will say that it has staying power and didn’t smudge or leave marks on my glasses all night which is my it gets 2 stars instead of one.

Then comes trying to remove my makeup so I start with a makeup removing wipe, following the instructions on the product page and it’s literally flaking off and all over my face, with quite a bit left on my lashes.

I then used makeup wipe #2 and same issue, black flecks all around my eyes and cheeks, and this time several lashes came off with the black specks. Then when I can see the wipes aren’t working I switch to eye make up remover liquid on a cotton round, letting it sit a bit on my lashes to try and loosen it up….

nope black flakes and more lashes on first one, number two still had significant black flecks, and using a magnifying mirror I can see to my horror that there is still mascara on my lashes. At this point I also still have the flecks on my face so I try eye makeup remover one more time, and then to get the last bits off my lashes and face I followed up with a third makeup remover wipe.

I have worn many mascaras, waterproof and regular and NEVER had to work this hard to remove it. I was very gentle and not rubbing my lashes or pulling them so it was frustrating for a product designed to enhance, to do the opposite causing me to lose lashes instead.

It’s not something I will use again, but it’s not worth the hassle of returning it either. Love the eye brightener, the mascara is just not for me!.

I’ve been using mascara since middle school & I’m now old(er) and, therefore, experienced. It’s taken almost a lifetime, during which I suspect I’ve tried using almost every mascara in existence. So many failures for me; so much money wasted–until now! This mascara is awesome! My sensitive eyes are no longer a problem.

From barely visible, scant, and short, my eyelashes are transformed to full and long. I quickly discovered it has no negative effects that every mascara tried previously has had: No flaking, itchy and red eyes anymore, and, using my usual eye makeup remover, removing it at night is quick and easy.

I must admit, after reading the few negative reviews, I did hesitate in making my purchase. However, thinking it wouldn’t end any worse than its trashed predecessors, I took (yet another) chance. I’m thrilled I made the right decision and will be ordering more, as well as trying other Thrive products.

I do have just one negative comment and that’s not even about the mascara: The shipping was fast, but the mascara didn’t arrive in a tightly sealed box and the wand (applicator) itself wasn’t secured (wound down) as tightly as I thought it should and would be.

In reflection, I probably should have returned it along with an explanation, but I didn’t want to take the time nor incur an additional expense. I might easily have never known I was holding my ideal mascara.

Having said that, I must add that if you feel as I did, that you’ve tried more than your share of mascaras, yet continue searching for your ideal, I suggest and highly recommend giving this mascara a try.

I am writing this review to help others who are on the fence about trying this mascara and to contradict some negative reviews about it. I have been using this mascara for at least 3 years and I really love it.

I have picked up other mascaras from time to time to try and either threw them away or returned them and went back to this one every time. It’s the best! I prefer waterproof mascara and I have tried almost everything out there over the years from cheap to very expensive and this is by far the best that I have ever used.

It stays on and it does not smear. I do not remove this mascara every night; in fact I wear it around 3 – 4 days before I take it off. Some may say that is not good for my eyes or eyelashes, but I have had no issues and I have extremely sensitive eyes and skin on my face.

I’m really not sure how applying and removing mascara every single day would not be worse pulling and tugging on your eyelashes. It does occasionally start to slightly flake when it is nearing time to take it off, but it still looks good.

I have had numerous compliments on the way my eyelashes look and I only apply it to my top lashes. I just choose not to put mascara on my bottom lashes because they are so small and fine. I noticed in the reviews that some people complain that it is difficult to remove.

Please keep in mind this is beach waterproof mascara and it should be difficult to remove with just something standard. It is very easily removed with eye make up removers such as Clinique take the day off and Lancome definicils and other waterproof mascara removers that you can buy at pretty much any store.

Anyway, this is great and easily removed waterproof mascara that I have kept coming coming back to for at least 3 years. I just ordered a new one and started it on March 1 and I am still wearing the same application today, March 4.

I’ve have one small flake. I will remove and apply new tomorrow. Can’t go wrong with this stuff!😀.

I have always been a waterproof mascara wearer as I prefer something a little longer wearing. I’m also in the pool every single day of our short, Upstate NY summer and I’m literally counting down the days to get back to tropical sandy beaches.

I was instantly drawn to this mascara because I feel it spoke to my soul. For starters, I love the tube. It makes it very easy to get just the right amount on the brush and you don’t waste a drop of product.

The brush is excellent! It really separates and defines every single lash. I don’t have clumps or “spider leg” lashes at all. It does dry pretty quick so it will hold a curl well. The key is to apply light layers (I do 3 layers, with the 3rd being mostly touch ups) where you can build a great lash look.

The product also isn’t super wet where it leaves dots all over the lids and it also isn’t super thick. It does provide great conditioning for the lashes too. Sometimes WP formulas can be drying, but this is anything but.

Here is the key- this is advertised as a Beach mascara. I take that as it is meant to stand up to the abuse of salt water, crashing waves, heat, and it definitely does all of that. I wouldn’t say this is for someone to wake up and apply at 6am and remove after a day at the office at 10pm.

If that’s you, try one of the other formulas as this is way more than what you need. I have blonde lashes and look like an alien without mascara, so I don’t dare to go into my pool (salt water) or any other pool without this on.

It holds up, just like it claims. But in the process, I’m sure some of those bonds are getting broken down and become weak because I have never, ever had an issue removing this product. I feel the secret is what I use, and have always used to remove eye makeup- Pure Virgin Coconut Oil.

Yep, the $6 jar you get in the cooking/baking oil is the BEST waterproof mascara remover ever! It will come right off! Overall, I LOVE this formula! It stays on well, looks great and doesn’t dry out my lashes!.

This is the best waterproof mascara ever made and I’ve tried them all. I swim and scuba dive and this doesn’t budge or flake. It holds the curl perfectly- even underwater! It’s truly amazing and I hope they never stop making it.

And vegan with great ingredients. I’ve used it for over a year now, and I believe my lashes are actually healthier. The only negative reviews I see claim it’s difficult to remove. It is, but not with the proper product- there’s a particular department store brand (starts with a C) Take the Day Off- use with a cotton ball and it comes off perfectly!.

Guys, first of all this stuff is overrated. Get the Lash Princess one in the Peach tube, that one is miles better for the reasons I’m gonna state later. With this particular one, this thing is runny and gets smudged like crazy.

If you accidentally get it on your lids or on your skin, it takes wayyy too long to dry up before you can use a spoolie to scratch it off. And it will stain. It also gets all over your eyes so easily no matter how careful you are.

Honestly super annoying. Second of all, this thing dries so slowly that if you spray setting spray afterwards it will run down your face and give you raccoon eyes. I know I should’ve covered my eyes before using setting spray but the peach tube didn’t smudge one me at all without covering my eyes so.

It doesn’t do as good as a job of lengthening my lashes like the peach one, and it actually holds my lashes down :/ And for the girlies who cry a lot in therapy (like myself), this mascara’s gonna run down your face.

If you cry a lot, get the peach one. You can rub your eyes and cry all you want and the only thing it will do is get rubbed away but NEVER leave your face with black streaks. This green one is overrated as heck, get the peach one.

i like that this mascara has a drier consistency compared to other mascaras i’ve tried. it dries fairly quickly. and of course, it made my lashes appear a LOT longer than they actually are. as someone with asian lashes (which tend to be completely straight, short, and slope downwards), this mascara really helped make them appear so much longer.

and it’s affordable price is another win! on the other hand, the mascara isn’t one i use a lot. the main reason being that i have generally oily skin, and the mascara leaves me with total racoon eyes.

i know there’s a waterproof version of this, but the formula of this version just hasnt really worked out for me. it never seemed to hold curl for me either, but that’s most likely because my lashes are naturally straight and slope downwards.

as you can see in the photo, it’s pretty banged up since ive had this tube for years LOL. i just use it here and there just to give my upper lashes a slightly thicker look. in short, i dont think this mascara is for me.

but i do believe it can work for someone with skin that is more on the normal/dry side!.

I’ve been using this mascara line for couple of years now and it’s absolutely amazing. I’ve used Purple one and recently thought to try green Lash Princess False lash effect. I have decent length straight lashes.

I didn’t use any lash curlers before application and still it gives thick false lashes look. I don’t mind clumpy thick lashes. I actually like that look instead of separate lashes. If your looking for very clean and individual lash look then this isn’t for you.

If you don’t mind thick chunkier lashes or them clamping togather then this is a beautiful budget friendly product. To show how this mascara is I didn’t wear anything at all other than mascara. Mascara wand is cone shape and it helps to lay down good amount of product but if you don’t want a lot don’t forget to wipe tip of wand.

There is no fall out and it’s not waterproof. For the purple princess mascara I’ll have separate review. But you can see the difference of wand shapes for the comparison. I love both.

This is my first experience of a vegan mascara hence I was quite excited to try it. Like vegan I found the mascara very natural and did not clump. If you are looking for a natural look this would be perfect.

Unfortunately it wasn’t what I look for in a mascara, it didn’t lengthen my lashes, or hold my curls when I curled my lashes. Although its waterproof I did find that I was able to remove it with ease with micellar water which was a pleasant change as I find that most waterproof mascara take me a lot of effort to remove which at times would ruin my skin.

I definitely found this low irritating and suitable for sensitive eyes like myself. Initially with the first few uses I found that when I put the wand back into the tube a mass of product would squeeze out on top which would be quite messy however this disappeared after a handful of uses.

I also found that this would often smudge under my eyes as well despite multiple attempts of powdering or trying other techniques. I think if the formula could be slightly improve to provide length and hold curls I would definitely consider this again as its a vegan product.

I was gifted a product sample to trial and review.

I wear contact lenses every day so need a mascara that is gentle on my eyes , and I’m pleased to say I had no issues with this one causing any sort of irritation at all. It’s definitely a dry formula so has taken a bit of a learning curve for me to get used to.

My lashes did not feel crunchy when wearing this mascara, which I love. I have sparse lashes so really look for something to volumise & plump them up while also giving me a little length too – I found this mascara does a decent job at both.

I really liked how it didn’t glug up and separated the lashes very well. I would say, for me , it gave a pretty , natural, yours but better lashes sort of look. Also, it didn’t flake or budge at all on me, huge plus there for no end of day panda eyes ! All in all a great mascara that I would recommend to others.

I was gifted a product sample to trial and review.

The box the mascara came in looked very professional. It was well labelled. I could see exactly what the product was and the brand name. Ere Perez sounded very unique for a brand name. I was very impressed that it was waterproof.

It’s great that it was waterproof because it won’t smudge if the eyes get watery. The white mascara tube looked great as well. It looked very professional. The way Ere Perez was written was very stylish.

It was very easy to open the lid. It was very easy to use the applicator to apply mascara to my eyes. The mascara didn’t get clumpy when I applied it and it was long lasting. I also liked the size of the mascara, it wasn’t too big.

I was gifted a sample to trial and review.

This mascara is great. I love the blue as it really enhances my eyes. The curved brush makes it easy to apply. It stays on well with not much flaking which is important as I sometimes wear contacts. It is easy to remove and does not irritate my eyes.

It also doesn’t have any irritating smell. As I said in the title is has sadly been discontinued. I have written to Inika but doubt it will do much good.

After not being able to wear eye-liner and mascara for many years without reactions I reached out to customer service for assistance. They did a lot of work finding the right products for me and for that I’m ridiculously grateful! This mascara is amazing in the sense that it did not give me a reaction, which is something so important! But there was some smudging which is why I only gave 4 stars.

If you have sensitive eyes, allergic to a lot of things and wanting to try something this is definitely an amazing start! So ridiculously grateful for their help!.

When it comes to makeup, natural based products often get a bad rep. It’s a common misconception that products using synthetic chemicals perform better, last longer, and are better overall… However, I have often found that natural products are just as good.

If not superior to some traditional products. The Inika Long Lash Vegan Mascara is one that definitely outweighs many of its more traditional cosmetic competitors. It contains a range of natural ingredients and is free from harsh synthetic ingredients (and additionally, animal derivatives) making it great for those with sensitive eyes.

Despite its natural ingredients it still performs incredibly well and does not compromise on quality. With a silky smooth texture that coats the lashes with ease, the consistency of this mascara strikes the perfect balance, it’s not too wet, yet it’s not dry either.

Thanks to this formula, this mascara does not clump and I can quite confidently say that in all the times I’ve used this, I haven’t once wanted to reach for a lash comb or been desperate to de-clump my lashes.

The mascara does an outstanding job at creating incredible length to the lashes, and also providing them with a load of volume, it’s often one thing or another when it comes to mascaras and it can often be a struggle to find one that provides you with both.

Using this, it’s immediately noticeable how much this mascara lifts and lengthens the lashes whilst also defining and adding volume. Straight and lacking in curl, my lashes generally need quite a bit of help in order to stand out.

Mascara brushes can be tricky, but this brush is one that doesn’t play on gimmicks. That being said, it isn’t your regular mascara brush either. The wand is a great balance in-between a traditional mascara wand, and a cutting-edge one.

The tapered brush allows you to get in at the root of the lashes and the density of the bristles means that the wand simultaneously applies product and combs through lashes at the same time. Although not waterproof, the mascara still puts up a good fight.

In the time that I’ve worn this, I haven’t experienced any excessive smudging or flaking and the wear time is very much comparable to mascaras which use synthetic chemicals (if not better) Most importantly of all, the finished result is incredible.

Whether you’re all about a natural makeup look, a red lip or a glamorous smoky eye this mascara makes an incredible difference to the overall appearance of each look. I’m super impressed by the results and highly recommend this product.

This mascara brush nicely fans the lashes. The mascara product goes on smoothly, without clumping. I found if I apply at 7-8am, by 5pm it’s flaking and making my eyes fatigued. I’ve tried with and without eyelash conditioner under the mascara but get the same results.

It feels nice through the day and I really like the fanned lashes, but wished it held out longer before needing to get it off to relieve my eyes, I have not had any stinging or burning. The lashes feel soft and look nice while wearing.

The only issues with the brush was some smearing to the upper and lower lids, easily removed with a q-tip and micellar water. Otherwise the brush nicely reaches the inner and outer lashes to coat them.

I am the same person who wrote the prior review and since I can’t edit it, I just wanted to give an updated evaluation of the product. It has actually grown on me quite a bit. I discovered that it was the residue from my oil cleanse that was causing the mascara to run and give me raccoon eyes.

Since I stopped oil cleansing, I have not had any problem with this mascara running, raccoon eyes, or flaking. Lasts all day. Also, I have extremely sensitive eyes and most mascaras, even other natural brands irritate my eyes, but this mascara does not.

It gives a decent amount of volume, pretty good, but not dramatic night time type of volume. And yes, it still is a very wet formula that you have to be careful with when applying. All that being said, I use it frequently as my daytime mascara and I do like it.

I do feel that it is a bit expensive, but I understand that it is actually organic, not just natural, hence the premium price tag. A very good mascara and if you’re not addicted to super high impact volume, you would honestly probably love it, especially if you have sensitive eyes.

I haven’t used mascara for years due to sensitivity issues but as I’ve gotten older and my eyes have started to become a little more hooded I decided to try again. Bought this as I’ve had one or two Inika products in the past and its honestly the best mascara I’ve ever used.

No irritation, goes on really well and stays put all day. Any clumps that appear on application comb out no problem. It makes my lashes appear really long and natural and also cleanses off well. I now use it every day and will definitely buy again.

It’s an outstanding product, the mascara actually make my thin eye lashes visible and attractive. The reason I started using your products is that you use of friendly ingredients. It’s been years since I’ve been able to wear much make up at all.

My eyes are sensitive and can become red and painful and I had to stop wearing mascara at all. Thank you Inika. I highly recommend your product to others who suffer with sensitive eyes D.

I have tried just about every brand of designer mascaras and have come to the conclusion that sometimes you need to combine two great mascaras to get the ultimate mascara with all the features you want.

I love this mascara as a top coat, it separates any clumps I get from a thickening mascara, and it truly fans out your lashes and makes them oh so long! I love to use Superfan after one coat of a thickening mascara, like Urban Decay’s lash freak.

By itself, lash freak is a bit too dramatic and clumps easily, and this one is a little too light and wispy for my taste. But together, the combination is a mascara lovers dream! No clumps – Dramatic, long, smudge and flake free lashes! Just like having extensions without the hassle or expense.

I highly recommend.

Magic. SuperFan is magic. Let me start off by saying, I don’t usually write reviews, but after a few years of this mascara being my eyelash’s soulmate, I was obliged to write this. I have hooded yes, am 39, and have oily skin.

I have battled my whole adult life with transfer underneath my eyes specifically, because of my oil skin. I usually opt for a waterproof mascara, have to powder under my eyes and wish for the best. At nearly 40, powder under my eyes is NOT going to be an option much longer due to the emerging fine lines.

I’ve tried Maneater, Rollerlash, Better Than Sex, Lash Idôle, Perversion, Lights Camera Lashes, Monsieur Big, Diorshow, Clinic High Impact, Hourglass Caution, Kush, Climax, Maneater, Lash Paradise, PACIFICA Vegan Collagen Fluffy Lash, CLINIQUE Bottom Lash Mascara and so many more that I can’t even remember.

This mascara, is the only one that does not transfer. Zero transfer. Zero smudging. No raccoon eyes. Not at 10am, not at 5 pm. No powder needed. Go ahead and moisturize under your eyes, its fine. It’s not going to transfer.

How? I don’t know. But I’m not even trying anymore to find a different mascara. I found the one that works and I’ve spent a lot of money on others that I can’t even wear. Is the brush perfect? No. Do I care? Not at all.

It doesn’t transfer. It’s not even waterproof and yet it stays where it’s supposed to. Good job Smashbox. This is the best mascara on planet Earth.

This is probably the best mascara I’ve had so far, seriously! My friend had got me this during Christmas of last year but I haven’t been able to use it till recently. I really like it because it makes my eyelashes super long and separated.

I’m Asian and I have very short eyelashes and my eyes are hooded. My eyelashes also like to clump together and With so little eyelashes to begin with, it looks like I only have 5 eyelash hairs. A mascara that would give volume for my eye shape would look too dramatic(at least for my taste) so I prefer something more lengthening.

Only thing I wish is that if they came out with a waterproof version. I have combo skin and my eyelashes also easily touched my bottom lid so it smears easily. I have to use a water proof mascara on top of this but it’s worth it.

This was my favorite mascara for quite a while before I discovered the Thrive mascara but this one still for sure holds its own and it’s waterproof so I always go back to this one when I want or need the waterproof formula.

I have unbelievably unruly and frustrating lashes that started a few years ago sticking in every direction, up, down in and out, and they’re all clumped together in some places, I have a lot of hair loss and that includes facial hairs so there are gaps between them and they’ve gotten horribly sparse so just all around horrible to work with so very few mascaras will work to help them out even a little bit but this is definitely one of them.

It lengthens and volumizes, doesn’t smudge or flake at all, stays on very well and is definitely waterproof! I have it in both waterproof and original and even though I use them both I like the waterproof more for some reason.

I feel like it goes on a little bit better and since I have very watery eyes it clearly helps having my makeup stay put! and at night it’s not difficult at all to wash it off. I always double cleanse with a balm/oil cleanser and then a regular face wash and the first cleanser takes it away in a matter of minutes.

The only thing I kinda wish was that the wand was a little bit different, I like the wands that are like the Thrive Cosmetics mascara or one end of the Huda legit lashes mascara, those wands that are fine and sparse and not thick and fluffy because that works way better for my annoying lashes and I think that it would be perfect if it had that kinda wand because the formula is so good and with the thicker wands the formula tends to goop up on that wand hairs and that can make it messy, I sometimes have to wipe some of it away before I use the mascara but other than that I love this product!.

Does this mascara go on thick and gloppy? Yes. But that works in your favor with the right technique. Get a dry spoolie brush and immediately comb through after the first layer, breaking up clumps. (Small disposal spoolie brushes are great.

) Let it dry 20-30 seconds before touching up the tips. Because this mascara stays wet for a few seconds, it gives you time to tweak your lashes, get rid of clumps, and wipe away dots that get on your skin.

You can also use a lash comb and/of a fine point to break up small clumps. Many waterproof mascaras don’t thicken very well, but I get decent lash thickening from this one. And like the not-too-dark black color because it isn’t harsh.

As a wearer of hard contacts I need a good waterproof mascara. Some waterproof mascaras flake apart after a few hours and get into my eyes. Ouch! This one seldom does that so makes it a repeat buy item.

To remove, use baby oil or unscented mineral oil. Cheap and fast removal. Moistures the skin around the eyes, too.

I don’t usually wear waterproof mascara, but today I spent all day at the waterpark and I wanted some thing that would hold up. I used a primer underneath it and applied only one coat. It looked great – full, thick lashes.

(For full lashes, a primer is really necessary with any mascara, I’ve found. ) I spent all day at the water park and when I got home in the evening my lashes looked like they did in the morning. The hard part was washing it off.

I made the mistake of using a cream-based cleanser first, when I should’ve used an oil-based eye-makeup remover. So I switched from the cream-based cleanser to the oil based one, and, using it as gently as possible, I was able to get the mascara off.

Because it is so difficult to come off, I would not wear this every day, only on the special occasions when I am going to go into a swimming pool, hot tub, or some other watery event. Definitely not an every day mascara! However, I was extremely impressed by the staying power.

So I would recommend this product.

I’ve never got on with natural mascaras as they are usually dry and flakey. But I am a big fan of Lily Lolo products (mineral foundation, silk finishing powder eyeshadows and makeup brushes) so I thought I’d give this mascara a go.

I am impressed with how well it stays on all day with no flakiness at all and how easily it’s removed at the end of the day. Also love the size and shape of the wand. However, it is hard work applying it.

It’s quite a thick, stiff consistency and takes a while to apply it. I do have long lashes so maybe this is part of the reason. I’ve only been using it a week or so and it’s already drying out in the tube.

That said, I wouldn’t necessarily rule out buying it again but it would be great if the consistency of the product could be improved.

This is my most favorite mascara! It doesn’t flake all over my face after a couple hours of wear. It’s easy to take off, unlike waterproof mascara. It makes my lashes look long and thick without looking clumpy.

My eyes have become very sensitive to what I put on or around them and this is the only mascara I found that doesn’t bother my eyes, the ingredients are right for me. Highly recommend. Though it is a bit pricier than your average drug store brand, the quality is much better.

This mascara made my lashes long longer and a bit fuller. All in all, I quite liked it. The problem is that it has a floral fragrance and it does not die down through wear! I put this on to test it out.

Had a lunch and halfway through, I had to remove it. I suffer from migraines and floral scents can absolutely give me a headache if it’s continuous. I only dinged one star because other than the unidentifiable floral scent, this mascara really is fantastic.

If floral scents give you headaches, I do not recommend this mascara. If you are unbothered by floral fragrances however, this is great!.

I received the Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara free for review from PINCHme and while I think it’s a great mascara it’s not going to become a favorite of mine anytime soon. While it does coat the lashes nicely and does a lovely job at lengthening I need a more volumizing formula.

I’m also not a fan of the brush. I was super intrigued initially but it is not a brush I have enjoyed using. It does apply a nice amount of product but I find any more than one coat of this mascara and my lashes just become spidery, dry looking, and difficult to comb through.

They do look nice with just one coat, holds curl, lengthens, and definitely darkens but two or more coats and it starts to look crumbly and flaky which I found very surprising with all the oils and waxes in this product.

I also found I make a big mess on my lower lashes when using the type of wand. I do still like the look with one coat, very natural and fluttery and doesn’t look dry at all. I love it for days when I’m not using heavy makeup and I just want a little definition for a more natural look.

If you’re going for a more voluminous or glam look this mascara might not be for you and I myself I hate the brush! But if you’re into a minimalist look, don’t hate a pokey brush, and you just want some length and definition from a clean beauty brand then this one might be for you.

I was so excited to receive this product from pinch me in exchange for my honest review. So here are My thoughts on this ilia limitless lash mascara. Let’s start off with the packaging. It is very nice sleek simple tube with a silky matte feel.

It feels of very good quality. The mascara wand doesn’t do it for me. Im not that much a fan of plastic wands they just don’t do much for my lashes which are stick straight and fine but hard to work with because there is an abundance of them.

And the fact that there is different sizes on the wand to define, lift and separate was a no go for me. I like brush bristle mascara where all the bristles are basically the same size. The smell is funky I mean I know all mascaras have a chemically smell but this one also has a hint of floral to it.

idk if that’s what it is and maybe because it’s something in there because its more natural idk but I smell floral and then chemical which doesn’t smell nice. And even after a while if I turn my head a certain way you can get a faint whiff of the smell.

The formula to me is way too wet. I prefer dry as a bone like too faced better than sex waterproof mascara and this compared to that is like trying to curl my lashes with water. It doesn’t apply evenly.

it is very clumpy and it weighs down my lashes so much that they are just heavily coated straight sticks it looks awful. I tried 2 layers and that was a mistake I had to wash it off and try again the next day.

And yes all the times I used this Mascara and I really gave it a lot of oppurtunies to wow me. I used a lash curler before hand. I will say that despite how heavily coated and droopy my lashes were they didn’t feel heavy at all it felt pretty weightless almost like nothing was on them which some people really like.

I like to be able to feel my mascara though like when it dries down. It’s clearly not a waterproof mascara so if you touch your eyes or rub on the lashes at all it will all come off. After 6 hours it was a mess.

So I’ll start with the positives first before listing the negatives and ultimately why I give the Ilia Limitless Lash Mascara only 2 stars. The packaging of this mascara feels very lux; it has a nice weight to it and a minimalist design.

The product itself has a nice floral scent and is a nice thick creamy consistency. This mascara is also promoted as 99% naturally derived which is a nice plus. The brush design is excellent with a single row, “comb” section that helps to evenly coat and separate lashes while the remaining bristles provide length and volume.

This mascara provides a very natural look which initially I loved. So much so that I ended up buying 3 more when FabFitFun had a crazy good bundle deal (I want to say I got them for $7 each). So why 2 stars? THIS MASCARA IRRITATED MY EYES SO BAD!!!! The first few times I wore it, my eyes would become dry but I didn’t think anything of it.

Then one day I made the mistake of using eye drops. Not only did this mascara smudge all around my eyes, but my eyes were BURNING after using the eye drops. I’ve used eye drops when using other mascaras and never had an issue.

I tried it again one more time this week before writing this review and found that once again my eyes were irritated to the point that I removed it within 1 hour. I generally love floral scents but not for products used around my eyes.

Overall, I am very disappointed that this mascara didn’t work for me given all the glowing reviews and awards. But as for me, I will be selling my remaining 3 unopened Ilia Limitless Lash Mascaras and never buy again.

I received this mascara for free in exchange for an honest review. Overall, this is a solid waterproof mascara! This was my first time ever using waterproof mascara and it left good impressions. Upon first application, I found it to be extremely lightweight and did not feel it on my lashes at all.

It’s also very natural, which is how I prefer my mascara. I think this mascara is great for a natural look, like a “my lashes but better” look, but might not be ideal for those who want intense volume and lengthening.

I think one coat is enough for a natural enhanced lashes look. More than one coat may cause a bit of clumping to occur. This mascara seems like a dry formula, which works well with my straight, thick lashes! It can hold a curl very well and is smudge-proof and does not flake! Since it is waterproof, I found it to be a little waxy, but I’m not sure if that’s just what a standard waterproof mascara is like.

Overall, this is fantastic for a natural look and this has become my new holy grail mascara!.