At 62 I surf big waves and swim long distances 2-5 miles per day 4-5 days/week). I was 5′ 11” tall, weighed 245, with a 31” inseam, 42″ waist, and 46-47″ chest, but slender arms with only 13. 5″ biceps.
This fall I hooked up a harness in my pool and lost 20 lbs. in 2 months of swimming 1-3 miles per day. At 225 lbs I was aiming for 210 lbs. , but the water temp cooled to 68 degrees and my 3/2mm wetsuit was not warm enough.
At first I layered a 1. 5mm neoprene shirt and got more warmth and less flushing, but my arm flexibility was reduced. I decided to test 4 backzip wetsuits for colder waters; 1. Hyperflex Voodoo 4/3mm XXL (LFS) 2.
O’Neill Epic 4/3mm XXL (GBS) 3. O’Neill HEAT 4/3mm XXL (LFS) 4. Quiksilver Syncro 5/4/3mm XXL (LFS) 1. Hyperflex Voodoo – My first shock was that the Voodoo was the hardest suit to put on by far even over a thin lycra bodysuit partly because of the non-slip fleece lining, but also because the arms were very tight even on my skinny arms, and the suit was very tight around my shoulders.
I needed help pulling the floodgate over my head, and to zip the suit up. Over all I felt like I was in a more restrictive 5mm “standard 50% flex neoprene” wetsuit rather than a 100% stretch suit. I could not imagine swimming 1/2 mile in this suit because of the lack of flexibility.
2. O’Neill Epic 4/3 mm XXL (GBS) AND 3. O’Neill HEAT 4/3mm XXL-short (LFS) The 2 O’neill suits both went on SO easily it absolutely shocked me, and both fit me absolutely perfectly even thought the HEAT was a 2XL-Short and the Epic just an XXL.
The Epic 4/3mm would have stretched out a bit more in length in the legs if I needed it to. The HEAT fit me perfectly like a body skin. The Neoprene in both suits was absolutely buttery, and both felt far more flexible than the Voodoo 4/3mm or than a NeoSport Xspan 5mm had felt a month earlier.
The heat retention of the front panel in both suits was immediately evident. The Liquid Fluid Seal over all the seams on the HEAT 4/3mm suit were totally stretchy, and the added back heat panels convinced me it would be significantly warmer than the Epic 4/3mm with GBS.
The shape of the neck in both suits put a little pressure on the front of my throat – perhaps because my posture is really poor – but this issue became completely unnoticeable once I took the Heat 4/3mm and then the Epic 4/3mm into the water.
4. Quiksilver Syncro 5/4/3mm XXL (LFS) – For a cold water suit, this would have been my second choice behind the O’neill HEAT 4/3mm with LFS. It went on easily even with the back floodgate, and I was able to zip it up without help from my wife.
The Neoprene felt absolutely wonderful and stretchy, and the suit felt totally comfortable once zipped up. I knew I could swim miles warmly in this suit. But it was at least 3-4 inches too long in the legs, and the arms were also a little long for me, bulging a little around my biceps, which would not be good in cold water.
If I lost the extra 20 lbs. the Quiksilver Syncro XXL would become way too loose. Since the O’neill HEAT 4/3mm obviously fit me the best, and would fit well at 20lbs less, it felt the warmest, and it felt flexible enough to do my longest swims, I put it back on, threw on some 5mm NeoSport booties, donned a swim cap and 3mm Neosport gloves, stepped down into a pool of 58 degree water, hooked myself into my swimming harness and swam a mile.
I felt NO water getting in through the neck, or the seams of the O’neill HEAT wetsuit, and I felt NO chill at all !!! In fact, after about a quarter mile I pulled down on the front collar to let in a little cool water as I heated up.
Seeing the recommended water temperature range of 45-60 degrees of the HEAT, I decided to immediately try the O’Neill Epic 4/3mm GBS too. In the 58 degree water I felt just a little more cool water seeping in than with the HEAT, but I was warmed up from the mile swim so I decided to swim another 1/2 mile.
The Epic swam so easy I decided to keep the O’neill Heat 4/3mm for waters 45-58 degrees, the O’neill Epic 4/3mm for 57-68 degrees, and my Neosport XSpan 3/2mm for waters 68 degrees and up.